Friday, July 1, 2022
HomeCanadian NewsDan Fumano: Vancouver council approves contentious Broadway plan

Dan Fumano: Vancouver council approves contentious Broadway plan


Controversial Broadway plan authorised Wednesday, after a defeated try to punt the problem till after the subsequent election.

Article content material

Vancouver council authorised the controversial Broadway plan late on Wednesday evening, after defeating an try to punt the entire difficulty till after the subsequent election.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Mayor Kennedy Stewart, talking in favour of the plan, described it as “an incredible plan” to develop the Broadway hall into “one of the crucial thrilling neighbourhoods within the nation,” dramatically rising housing choices — particularly for renters — whereas additionally aiming to guard present tenants.

However TEAM Coun. Colleen Hardwick, who has been extremely vital of the plan, predicted its added density will result in displacement of renters and better rents and residential costs and arguing it “promotes a false narrative of lack of provide.”

After the vote, Hardwick stated that if she is profitable in her run for mayor this yr, and TEAM elects a majority to council, they might “completely” attempt to repeal the Broadway plan.

“Clearly the subway is occurring, there’s little doubt about that. However there’s a superb planning course of, and there’s a foul planning course of, and this has been a foul one,” Hardwick stated. “I do suppose there’s a proper approach, and I feel there’s the potential to course-correct after the election.”

Commercial 3

Article content material

Together with Stewart, seven different members of council supported the plan general and voted in favour of most components of it: Inexperienced Couns. Adriane Carr, Pete Fry and Michael Wiebe, OneCity Coun. Christine Boyle, and ABC Couns. Lisa Dominato, Rebecca Bligh and Sarah Kirby-Yung.

Together with Hardwick, NPA Coun. Melissa De Genova and COPE Coun. Jean Swanson stated they might not assist the plan, and voted in opposition to most items of it.

Earlier on Wednesday, council rejected Hardwick’s try to delay the plan till after October’s election. Close to the tip of a sixth day of public conferences on the problem, she proposed sending the entire plan, with amendments, again to workers to “undertake neighbourhood-based planning with the affected communities and produce it again to council for consideration after the 2022 municipal election.”

Commercial 4

Article content material

Hardwick’s proposal to postpone a choice on the plan was supported by Wiebe and De Genova. However the remainder of council voted in opposition to the delay, and a heated alternate ensued.

The plan contemplates the subsequent 30 years for an space of just about 500 metropolis blocks alongside the Broadway subway line, which is below building, envisioning rising the inhabitants of the hall described as Vancouver’s “second downtown.” It units a course for extra density to the realm, the place metropolis corridor expects the inhabitants to extend from about 78,000 residents to as a lot as 128,000, and from 84,000 jobs to nearer to 126,000.

Greater than 200 individuals signed as much as tackle council on the plan, one of many highest totals for a single merchandise in current reminiscence, and council heard impassioned arguments for and in opposition to it.

Commercial 5

Article content material

Hardwick stated the truth that council members had ready greater than 40 amendments to the plan confirmed it was “not prepared for prime time.”

By referring the plan again to workers, Hardwick stated, “the brand new council can get began with this with a contemporary set of eyes and contemporary perspective. … We’re making an attempt to ram it via earlier than the tip of our time period, and that’s inappropriate.”

Different councillors disagreed that something was being rammed via, contemplating greater than three years of workers work and public consultations had gone into the plan.

“What’s behind this referral?” requested Bligh. “The truth is the mover of this referral votes in opposition to 90 per cent of improvement.”

Hardwick objected to that characterization from Bligh. The 2 councillors ran collectively below the NPA banner within the 2018 election, however will signify completely different events on this October’s election.

Commercial 6

Article content material

When Mayor Kennedy Stewart spoke subsequent, Hardwick objected once more and the assembly grew to become extra heated.

Stewart stated: “It’s not truly a referral that’s being debated right here, it’s the entire idea of the plan. So I might simply say, don’t refer it, vote in opposition to it. I feel a referral is just not genuinely what’s being debated right here, I feel if there’s elementary issues with this plan, referring it again is just not doing public service.”

“I do agree with Coun. Bligh, that if you’re in opposition to the Broadway subway, and in opposition to the extension to UBC, and in opposition to 90 per cent of the stuff that involves council, after all you’re going to be in opposition to this plan,” Stewart stated. “However actually state your intentions, don’t faux to do this with a referral. Simply vote in opposition to the plan.”

Commercial 7

Article content material

Hardwick objected and stated: “I really feel I’ve been maligned by two council members,” specifically Bligh and the mayor.

Stewart replied that citing a councillor’s voting report on public issues was not the identical as maligning somebody.

Carr, who was chairing the assembly, urged the councillors to deal with one another with respect, even once they disagree.

The plan has been described, by each supporters and opponents as one in every of Vancouver’s largest city-building selections in a minimum of a era.

Brent Toderian, a former chief planner for Vancouver, argued in a current Vancouver Solar commentary that the plan’s imaginative and prescient for a denser, transit-oriented future is required for town to sort out interconnected crises associated to housing, local weather, social fairness, public well being, and infrastructure.

The Broadway plan is daring, which is one cause it’s controversial, Toderian wrote, “however it’s what completely must be accomplished if we care concerning the future and are keen to again up our personal rhetoric.”

Different outstanding voices disagreed. In one other Vancouver Solar commentary this week, David Ley, a professor emeritus of city geography on the College of B.C., predicted the plan will result in will increase in land values, the lack of at the moment present reasonably priced rental housing, and the displacement of renters dwelling there immediately.

dfumano@postmedia.com

twitter.com/fumano

Commercial 1

Feedback

Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a vigorous however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. Now we have enabled e mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e mail should you obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a consumer you comply with feedback. Go to our Group Tips for extra data and particulars on regulate your e mail settings.



RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments